Volume 11: Cornwall

Select a site alphabetically from the choices shown in the box below. Alternatively, browse sculptural examples using the Forward/Back buttons.

Chapters for this volume, along with copies of original in-text images, are available here.

Current Display: Minster 1 (Waterpit Down), Cornwall Forward button Back button
Overview
Present Location
Roadside, on left of unclassified road from Tintagel to Davidstow, 0.5 km beyond junction with B 3266
Evidence for Discovery
First recorded 1838 in pre-sent location (Penaluna 1838, ii, 111). Shaft moved c. 1856 to nearby farm, Trekeek, where used to work 'the pivot of the horse-power of a threshing machine' (Maclean 1873, 586). Base remained in situ and in June 1889 shaft was returned to it (Langdon, Arthur 1890–1, 38).
Church Dedication
Present Condition
Monument broken but stable; ornament worn, much lichen; text badly worn; situation poor: exposed position
Description

The shaft only of a tapering, rectangular-section cross. It is slightly broken at the top, perhaps when the cross-head was knocked off. In the top of the shaft are the remains of the rectangular socket (9 x 13 cm and 10 cm deep) into which the cross-head would have been morticed. The shaft has a double flat-band moulding which frames the decoration on the front and back, and a single moulding down the sides. The decoration, in very low relief, is carved in long panels, which are not formally separated in any way. Langdon (1896, 376) illustrates a tenon at the base of the shaft, formed by cutting in the sides of the shaft, but merely tapering gently in the front and back. However this tenon is not now visible as the shaft is set in a base, probably its original one.

A (broad): In the upper half of the shaft, a broad band undulates from side to side down the shaft, with triquetra knots filling the volutes. Most of the strands between the knots cross beneath the main band, rather than regularly under and over. The panel below this contains the eroded remains of an inscribed text. The text is incised in five horizontal lines in a panel measuring 59 cm high by 29 cm. The letters measure between 5 and 8 cm in height but are now so deteriorated that it is not certain what script was used nor if the text was complete.

The text reads:

In the lower part of the shaft is a panel of interlace formed by a broad flat band with a median-incised line. The pattern is too worn to decipher.

B (narrow): The whole panel is filled with a simple plant trail, with a single large leaf in each spandril.

C (broad): This face is extremely worn. In the upper two thirds of the shaft is a panel of interlace, with small low bosses separating the registers of the pattern; the pattern may be Carrick Bends (simple pattern F). Below this are two large, diagonally crossed rings.

D (narrow): The upper panel contains a simple twist in the upper panel with a simple spiral plant-scroll below.

Discussion

Although this cross has some unique details, most of its features are typical of the Mid and East Cornwall group of early sculpture (Chapter IX, p. 91). These include the tapering shaft, the low-relief carving, and decoration which is a mixture of plant scrolls and trails and poorly constructed interlace. Features which are unique to this cross include the motif in the top panel on the front (Ill. 140), which is similar to the serpentine animal seen in the West Penwith group (p. 89), but as Langdon says: 'in the present instance there does not appear to have been a dragon's head' (Langdon, Arthur 1896, 375–6).

As noted in the introduction (p. 92), this cross is closely linked to others in the area, especially the two important crosses of Cardinham 1 and St Neot 3 (Ills. 43–6, 155–8). Its tapering form and overall proportions are very similar to both these monuments and with a spiral scroll (as on Cardinham 1) on one side and an acanthine scroll (as on St Neot 3) on the other, it combines elements from each. It has a stronger resemblance to Cardinham, which also has undivided panelled decoration.

The text on the Minster cross reads: [C.V.–CC] but this is now too deteriorated to be interpreted (Ill. 144). The text has always been in poor condition and various different readings have been suggested (see Okasha 1993, 320). Most of these agree on the reading of the first word as crux 'cross', which fits the traces remaining today. This might have been followed by a personal name.

None of the decoration on the cross-shaft can be closely dated; the suggested dating therefore reflects the range for the group as a whole.

This cross lies on a ridge-top, strategically located beside a modern road and historic trackway over an area of former downland around the head of the River Camel and at the northern end of the Great Cart-Track over Bodmin Moor, discussed in relation to the Doniert Stone (St Cleer 2, p. 135). Tucked into a valley head 2.4 km (1.5 miles) due north of the monument is Minster church, potentially the site of a pre-Norman monastery (Thomas, A. C. 1993, 109–10; Turner 2006a, 36, 38, 161), while 2.9 km (1.8 miles) to the north-east is Lesnewth whose name, lys nowydh 'new court', implies the court of a native Cornish ruler (Padel 1985, 150; Padel 1988, 109). The cross might originally have been associated with either of these.

Date
Late tenth to eleventh century
References
Penaluna 1838, ii, 111; Polsue 1870, 365; Maclean 1873, 585–6 and fig.; Langdon, Arthur and Allen, J. R. 1888, 314–15, 317, 324; Langdon, Arthur 1889a, 319, 335, 340–3, 345–6 and fig.; Langdon, Arthur 1890–1, 36, 38–41, 49–51, 53, 56–7, 90, 92 and figs.; Langdon, Arthur and Allen, J. R. 1895, 52, 58, 60, no. 40 and fig.; Langdon, Arthur 1896, 374–7, passim and figs.; (—) 1896, 145, 150–2 and figs.; Daniell 1906, 245, 337; Langdon, Arthur 1906, 411–12, 419, 438, 443n, 445, pl. VI, fig. 43; Macalister 1929, 192; Hencken 1932, 270, 276, 304; Macalister 1949, 180, no. 1050, and fig.; Ellis, G. 1952–3c, 58; Ellis, G. 1952–3d, 87; Ellis, G. 1959–61b, 196–8 and figs.; Ellis, G. 1959–61e, 274–5; Pevsner 1970, 120; Laing, L. 1975, 140; Todd 1987, 296; Langdon, Andrew 1992a, 55, no. 83, and fig.; Okasha 1993, 318–21 and passim, no. 74, fig. II.74; Thomas, A. C. 1993, 114; Turner 2006a, 163, 165
Endnotes

Forward button Back button
mouseover