Volume 8: Western Yorkshire

Select a site alphabetically from the choices shown in the box below. Alternatively, browse sculptural examples using the Forward/Back buttons.

Chapters for this volume, along with copies of original in-text images, are available here.

Current Display: Ilkley 08a–b, West Riding of Yorkshire Forward button Back button
Overview
Present Location
Now joined together and set up on top of Ilkley 1, at the west end of the nave under the tower.
Evidence for Discovery
The lower part of the head was found built into a Calvary constructed in the grounds of Middleton Lodge by Mr Peter Middleton (d. 1866). It was donated to the church in 1914 and placed in its present position on Ilkley 1, united with the upper part, which was found in the river Wharfe in 1884 (Collingwood 1915a, 92; Collyer and Horsfall Turner 1885, 49). See also Ilkley (All Saints) 1.
Church Dedication
All Saints
Present Condition
Broken, incomplete and worn. The lower arm is replaced by modern concrete, and there is also a modern infilling between the upper arm and the main section with the side arms.
Description

A cross-head in two fragments, type A9. Although found separately at different times, they fit together convincingly in spite of the slight gap, an impression reinforced by considerations of iconography and style. Both broad faces are edged with mouldings, probably squared but very worn.

A (broad): The central boss is not raised and is surrounded by a triple roll moulding. The upper arm has a battered figure, with wings and a nimbus, and unidentifiable features in the spaces above his shoulders. The side arms have birds perched in vestigial plant-scroll, biting at berry bunches. The bird in the left arm has a backward-turned head.

B (narrow): The sides of the arms are plain but with edge mouldings on the ends of the upper and side arms, in the curve of the armpit, and on the bottom of the side arm.

C (broad): A plain central boss with a single raised moulding. The left side arm has a bird facing left with a long double-outlined wing, and with its downward pecking head in the bottom left corner, just in front of its three-toed foot. It perches among narrow lacing strands with no vestige of leaf or berry bunch, which extend above and below the central roundel and enter the right arm, which is now completely worn smooth. These strands cross with independent strands from the lower, missing arm and from the upper arm, which also pass on either side of the central roundel. In the upper arm the strands cross, and that on the right develops into a spiral, while the other becomes a diagonal through the spiral. The end of the spiral and the diagonal terminate with a nod to the plant form in the upper corners of the arm, and there is also a drop leaf from the left of the spiral.

D (narrow): This face must originally have been like B but is now worn completely smooth.

F (bottom): The mouldings framing plain panels have survived underneath the arm to the right of face A; although the other side is more worn, the edge mouldings can still be seen.

Discussion

An interesting aspect of this head is the use of strands crossing from arm to opposite arm instead of spreading from arm to adjoining arm. The use of the 'right-angled crossing' is seen as characteristic of Manx sculpture, and to have been brought into west Yorkshire — where it appears on Aberford 3, Collingham 5, Kirkby Wharfe 1 and 3, and Saxton 1 — by Norse-Irish invaders who also occupied the Isle of Man (Bailey 1980, 219; and see Chap. V, p. 49). Its presence here however could suggest that the Norse settlers were influenced by an existing Anglian iconography which they adapted to their own style.

On the bird in the inhabited plant-scroll with its down-bent head, there are clear signs of influence from a similar bird in the scroll on Otley 1D (Ill. 567; see Chap. V, pp. 52–3, and Figs. 14d, g).

It is possible that the figure in the upper arm (Ill. 343) is the angel/man symbol of the Evangelist St Matthew: if so it belongs to the type in which the Evangelist is represented by his symbol, as on the cross-head from Hart, co. Durham (Cramp 1984, pl. 82.417). The remaining side arms certainly do not have other symbols, however. The St Matthew symbol is represented on the shaft of Ilkley 1 (Ills. 337, 342); and a possible St Matthew with his angel in the upper arm of a cross-head, on Dewsbury 9 (Ill. 220), and on the shaft of Otley 1 (Ills. 575–6; but see Chap. VI, pp. 63–4). Whether or not the figure on Ilkley 8 is an angel or an Evangelist symbol, it represents an important theme in the pre-Viking sculpture of the region.

Date
Ninth century
References
Allen 1884a, 166, 167, 171, fig. E facing 166; Allen and Browne 1885, 353; Collyer and Horsfall Turner 1885, 49, fig. E facing 48; Browne 1885c, 157; Browne 1888, 297; Allen 1891, 169, nos. 9, 10; Collingwood 1915a, 192–4, 281, figs. q–s on 193; Collingwood 1916–18, 46, fig. 25; Collingwood 1927, 48, 86–7, fig. 63; (–––) 1936, 99; Kendrick 1938, 199n; Pevsner 1959, 277; Taylor, H. M. 1968a, 330; Faull 1986b, 38; Wood, I. 1987, 36; Marshall 1996, n.p.; Hawkes 2003b, 366
Endnotes
[1] The following are general references to the Ilkley stones: Camden 1607, 567–8; Gough 1789, III, 239; Whitaker 1812, 217; Hatton and Fox 1880, 12; Browne 1880–4a, lxxiv; (–––) 1882a, 384; Cobley 1882, 127–8; Allen 1883, 53–6; Allen 1884, 158–61; Allen and Browne 1885, 353; Browne 1885c, 157; Allen 1889, 12, 158, 226, 227; Allen 1890, 293, 295; Irvine 1894, 328–9; Bogg 1904, fig. on 31; MacMichael 1906, 362; Collingwood 1915b, 328, 331; Browne 1916, 50; Collingwood 1932, 51, 53; Brown 1937, 213; Pevsner 1959, 20, 277; Taylor, H. M., 1968a, 330; Faull 1981, 218, 219; Faull 1986b, 29, 31, 37–40, pl. IX; Ryder 1991, 30; Ryder 1993, 160; Cambridge 1995b, 146–7; Hadley 2000a, 237, 238; Hawkes 2003a, 81–2; Butler 2006, 93.

Forward button Back button
mouseover