Volume 13: Derbyshire and Staffordshire

Select a site alphabetically from the choices shown in the box below. Alternatively, browse sculptural examples using the Forward/Back buttons.

Chapters for this volume, along with copies of original in-text images, are available here.

Current Display: Alstonefield 06, Staffordshire Forward button Back button
Overview
Present Location
In the churchyard, not far from the south porch
Evidence for Discovery
Although Purchas (1898–9, 87) refers to the pre-Norman remains as generally 'having been met with in the course of repairs', an event Pape (1945–6, 27) attributes to the restoration of the church in 1875, it is difficult to reconcile this piece with having been reused as building material. It is quite blackened and there are no indications of dressing-off, suggesting it was found in the churchyard, or nearby, or even brought to the church from elsewhere. It is not known when the sundial was set into it.
Church Dedication
St Peter
Present Condition
Blackened, presumably through air pollution, with its upper portion apparently truncated where it meets the base of the sundial. The lower portion of the stone is undamaged but undecorated.
Description

This is an ovoid-sectioned cross-shaft of the type generically referred to as a ‘round shaft’ (type g: Cramp 1991, xiv, fig. 1). As such, there are no clear faces except at the top where it has been cut into four roughly-shaped tapering flat surfaces (c. 15–20 cm (5.9–7.9 in) in height) which terminate beneath the sundial. These are separated from the cylindrical shaft, which is not entirely symmetrical, by a rolled collar moulding, parts of which are missing. The shaft now has a smooth appearance, probably through weathering, and the upper portion, above the collar, is undecorated.

Discussion

Although incomplete, this clearly represents the remains of a round-shafted cross of which there are several examples in the region (e.g. Ilam 2, Ills. 551-2, 554-5; Bakewell 25, Ills. 57-60; Brailsford 1, Ills. 127-30). Pape regarded this monument type as a separate group and, indeed, included them in a separate paper from those of the more common rectangular cross-sectioned shafts (Pape 1945-6). However, other examples of round-shafts where decoration is present, suggests that this distinction is potentially misleading as the monument form is the only factor distinguishing them.

Many of the round-shafted crosses are ovoid in section and, in this region, tend to have plain lower shafts. The Roman road from Derby to Buxton and Manchester, the present A515, passed close to Alstonefield and it is probable that this shaft, and others in the vicinity, represent reused Roman milestones (cf. Fig. 35, p. 86). The roughly cut nature of the squared upper section may mean that the collar moulding below was damaged when this was struck. While it is possible that the flat surfaces were squared off when the sundial was added, they are more weathered and in a different cut from the sundial above. This strongly supports the suggestion that the shaft represents a pre-existing column that, intended to be converted into a round-shafted cross shaft, was abandoned when the carving of the upper section damaged the collar moulding, leaving the monument unfinished. Alstonefield 11 below represents another example of a possibly unfinished shaft.

Date
Possibly tenth century
References
Purchas 1898–9, 88; Collingwood 1923, 9; Jeavons 1945–6, 120–1, pl. XXV.4; Pape 1945–6, 25–6, 31; Steele 1947–8a, 118–19, pl. XII.5; Steele 1947–8b, 173; Fisher 1968, 57; Plunkett 1984, 138, 286; Sidebottom 1994, 136, 137, 148, 218 (Alstonefield 15); Greenslade 1996b, 23–4; Sharpe 2002, 98–9; Bailey 2010, 34, 36, 76
P.S.
Endnotes
[1] The following are non-specific references to monuments at Alstonefield: Purchas 1898–9, 87; (—) 1900, 196; (—) 1914–15, 204; (—) 1930–1, 163; Pape 1930–1, 145–6; (—) 1934–5, 85; Steele 1947–8a, 119; Steele 1947–8b, 173; Butler 1964, 112; Fisher 1968, 57; Pevsner 1974, 54–5; Plunkett 1984, 145–9, 285; Leonard 1995, 71; Greenslade 1996b, 21, 23–4; Sharpe 2002, 58

Forward button Back button
mouseover