Volume 8: Western Yorkshire

Select a site alphabetically from the choices shown in the box below. Alternatively, browse sculptural examples using the Forward/Back buttons.

Chapters for this volume, along with copies of original in-text images, are available here.

Current Display: Otley 06, West Riding of Yorkshire Forward button Back button
Overview
Present Location
Otley Museum, Civic Centre, Cross Green, Otley
Evidence for Discovery
Possibly the 'rudely carved stone', thought to be the end of a supposed Roman coffin, which was said by Cobley (1882, 52) to represent 'a Roman soldier, holding the vexillum, or hand standard'. This was found 'let into the south wall of the Baptistery' during the lowering of the floor in the work carried out in 1867.
Church Dedication
All Saints
Present Condition
All faces are worn and face C has been completely worn or dressed smooth.
Description

This is part of a very small and thin monument, perhaps in its final form a slab rather than a shaft. The edges are rounded.

A (broad): Almost filling this face is a frontal figure in a short tunic. He has a round almost featureless head (although faint traces of eyes and nose remain), shoulders rounding in a boneless curve into his upper arms, and pointed feet both facing left. In his right hand he holds a sword with a distinctive pommel. His left hand is worn but appears to grasp another weapon with a pointed end curved in front of his body. He is framed on either side by the staffs of other weapons — clearly a spear on his right, although its head curves towards the top of the figure's head. There may be a straighter spear on his left, but its head is not clear. This may instead be a chair on which the figure is meant to be seen as seated, as suggested in Collingwood's drawing (1915a, 228, fig. u). The fringed elements on either side above can be interpreted as the foot (on the right) and part of the tail of a creature— a dragon according to Collingwood, or a bird.

B (narrow): Three volutes of a simple scroll, clumsy but still organised into alternate facing volutes, with a terminal at the top which bends back on itself and throws off two simple buds at each upper corner. The volutes end in tri-lobed forms, variously fruit and leaf-like, and there are small pointed buds in two of the spandrels.

C (broad): Dressed smooth

D (narrow): An irregular interlace ending in what could be a narrow Stafford Knot (simple pattern E) at the top. It is very shallow with a smoothly rounded narrow strand.

Discussion

In its style and layout and lack of clear crossings, the interlace on face D is very reminiscent of that on one face of the arm fragment Otley 11 (Ill. 603). This was probably a very slim monument, which may have been cut down to further its use as a grave stone. The sides certainly do not appear to represent the full width of the original designs, and the scroll on face B is either actually earlier than the carving on the front or a very fair stab at an earlier pattern — in which case why is it not at its full width? The pattern on face D has crossings very reminiscent of the scroll on face B of the head fragment Otley 7 (Ill. 598). Is this what would be left if part of such a head was pared down? This piece is actually the same stone as Otley 7, part of the head of a much earlier cross.

The figure carving has a close companion in the piece from Weston, across the river Wharfe from Otley (p. 268, Ills. 777, 781), and appears like it to be a memorial to an individual, reflecting the 'martial ideal' of the patrons, either Scandinavians or with a Scandinavian-influenced taste, rather than a Christian theme (see Chap. VII, p. 75). That stone also appears to have been cut down from an earlier sculpture, probably a cross-head.

Date
Tenth century
References
Allen 1891, 228–9, no. 5; Speight 1900, 35, pls. on 36; Bogg 1904, fig. on 30; Collingwood 1912, 130; Collingwood 1915a, 229, 273, 289, 292, figs. t–v on 228; Collingwood 1927, 152, 163, fig. 175t–v; Cramp 1982, 13, 17, pl. 20 (centre); Wood, I. 1987, 23, 36; Lang 1991, 37, 84; Wood, P. 1999, 6, fig. 8; Hadley 2000a, 238; Lang 2001, 36, 143
Endnotes
[1] The following are general references to the Otley stones: Browne 1880–4a, lxxiv; Allen and Browne 1885, 353; Allen 1890, 292, 293; Allen 1891, 229; MacMichael 1906, 364; Morris 1911, 373; Collingwood 1915a, 224, 231; Collingwood 1915b, 328; Collingwood 1927, 47; Brown 1937, 185; Mee 1941, 276; Pevsner 1959, 20, 385–6; Taylor, H. M. 1968b, 330, 331; Cramp 1970, 56; Faull 1981, 218, 219; Wood 1987, 20; Lang 1991, 38, 67, 84; Ryder 1991, 38; Ryder 1993, 22, 169; Hadley 2000a, 238; Hawkes 2003a, 83; Hawkes 2006a, 107.

Forward button Back button
mouseover